**Methods of Scoring Essay Items**
1. Holistic Scoring
Holistic scoring evaluates the overall quality of the essay. The scorer reads the entire essay and assigns a single score based on the overall impression of the writing. This method is quick and simple, useful for large-scale assessments but may lack detailed feedback and can be subjective.
2. Analytic Scoring
Analytic scoring breaks down the essay into specific components (e.g., content, organization, grammar, style) and scores each component separately. The total score is the sum of the scores for each component. It provides detailed feedback, is more objective and reliable, but is time-consuming and requires clear criteria for each component.
3. Primary Trait Scoring
Primary trait scoring focuses on the primary trait or main characteristic essential for the essay's purpose. For example, if the essay's goal is to persuade, the scoring focuses on the effectiveness of the argument. It is tailored to the specific purpose of the essay and helps target key skills but may overlook other important aspects of writing.
4. Rubrics
Rubrics use a scoring guide that defines specific criteria and performance levels for different aspects of the essay. Rubrics can be holistic or analytic. They set clear expectations for students and ensure consistency in scoring but require effort and expertise to develop effectively.
**Guidelines for Scoring Examination Essays**
1. Develop Clear Criteria
Define specific criteria for scoring, such as clarity, coherence, argumentation, evidence, grammar, and spelling. Ensure that criteria align with the learning objectives of the course or assessment.
2. Create a Rubric
Develop a detailed rubric that outlines performance levels (e.g., excellent, good, fair, poor) for each criterion. Share the rubric with students before the examination to guide their writing.
3. Ensure Consistency
Train scorers to use the rubric consistently. Conduct norming sessions where scorers practice applying the rubric to sample essays and discuss discrepancies. Consider using multiple scorers for each essay to increase reliability. Average the scores or resolve discrepancies through discussion.
4. Provide Detailed Feedback
Give students feedback on each criterion, highlighting strengths and areas for improvement. Use specific examples from the essay to illustrate points.
5. Maintain Objectivity
Score essays anonymously to avoid bias. Remove or conceal identifying information. Focus on the content and quality of the writing rather than the student's previous performance or reputation.
6. Manage Time Effectively
Allocate sufficient time for scoring, especially if using analytic scoring or detailed rubrics. Pace yourself to maintain accuracy and avoid fatigue, which can affect judgment.
7. Review and Revise
Periodically review and revise the scoring criteria and rubrics based on feedback and experience. Reflect on the scoring process and seek ways to improve fairness and accuracy.
Implementing these methods and guidelines will enhance the reliability and validity of essay scoring, provide valuable feedback to students, and ensure a fair assessment of their writing skills.
0 Comments